Skip to content

Americans’ favorite pizza toppings

    Americans' favorite pizza toppings

    When it comes to pizza varieties and toppings, there is no limit to the amount of ingenuity that may be employed or the most effective combinations. Some individuals prefer conventional pizzas, which consist of a red sauce, cheese, and a few toppings. Others, on the other hand, desire to experiment with unusual food combinations, such as arugula, kale, and chopped walnuts. Let’s take a deeper look at a few distinct types of pizza and the distinguishing traits between them.

    Most Ordered Pizza In America

    Can you determine which pizza varieties are the most common and the most popular? A basic cheese pizza covered with marinara sauce is one of the most popular pizzas in the world. It would appear that the combination of melted cheese, garlic, and Italian-style herbs baked on top of a crispy dough fulfils all of the flavour and texture benchmarks that every pizza aficionado desires.

    Despite this, a YouGov America study indicated that pepperoni pizza is by far the most often ordered form of pizza in the United States. Why? Pepperoni has a more soft texture than salami and mixes wonderfully with a wide array of sauces, cheeses, and crust types. Its flavour is salty and savoury, with just the proper amount of heat. Other common pizza variants include roasted vegetables topped with pesto, grilled chicken served with Alfredo sauce, and a meat-pizza lover’s topped with a spicy buffalo sauce that is ideal for tailgating.

    Most Common Crust Styles In The US

    There are many various types of pizza crust, and it is up to you to choose the one you want. There are times when you crave the familiarity of a traditional pan pizza crust and other times when you want to try something new and interesting, such as a caramelised deep-dish pizza crust with gooey melted cheese on the pizza’s edge. The following are the most common types of crust:

    Pizza Toppings Do Americans Love The Most

    Thin Crust

    A thin-crust pizza, commonly known as a Neapolitan pizza crust, is constantly listed as one of the most popular options for pizza enthusiasts. This sort of crust offers a light and crisp base for the pizza and is most typically seen on wood-fired Margherita pizzas.

    New York

    When you want to get a huge piece of pizza to eat while strolling down the street, you should order a slice of New York-style pizza. This type of pizza’s crust is comprised of a crispy outside edge and a soft interior crust that allows it to remain flexible and fluffy. These qualities are both desirable in a pizza crust.

    St. Louis

    Despite being sliced into squares or rectangles rather than wedges, pizza with a St. Louis crust has a light base and is simple to enjoy on the go. This makes eating this style of pizza quite unconventional. A St. Louis crust is constructed of unleavened dough and resembles a wafer-thin cracker.

    Deep Dish

    The Chicago-style crust is occasionally used to refer to the thicker and more bread-like crust of the deep-dish pizza. One of the reasons why deep-dish pizza is so popular is that the crust ledge keeps the sauce, cheese, and toppings in place so that they don’t fall off when you bite into a slice.


    Detroit Crusts of the Detroit or Sicilian style are notoriously thick and chewy and are typically served in large rectangular slices. This pizza inverts the traditional pizza layering by placing the toppings on the bottom, followed by the cheese, and finally the sauce.

    Most Common Pizza Sauce

    What pizza toppings are Americans most fond of?
    Your choice of pizza sauce can have a significant impact on the flavour of your pizza. These are some of the most common varieties of pizza sauce:


    When most people consider eating pizza, they envision a tasty tomato-based red sauce covering the crust. This marinara sauce is the most popular pizza sauce since it complements so many toppings, including meats, cheeses, and vegetables.


    Buffalo The flavour profile of this sauce goes wonderfully with a number of toppings, including crumbled grilled chicken, pieces of blue cheese, and bacon bits.


    If you are looking for a pizza sauce that is loaded with basil and garlic, you should try using pesto sauce. Pesto sauce is among the most popular pizza toppings. Possible toppings for a pizza topped with pesto sauce include grilled eggplant, roasted chicken, olives, and parmesan cheese.

    The Most Popular Cheeses And Meats

    What pizza toppings are Americans most fond of?
    Consistently regarded as one of the most popular pizza topping combinations, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, and mushrooms topped with traditional marinara sauce are one of the most popular pizza topping combination. In addition, popular pizza topping and sauce combinations include chicken and garlic with Alfredo sauce, roasted vegetables with Italian sausage and pesto, and pesto with roasted vegetables.

    Among the most popular cheeses for pizza are:

    • Monterey Jack.
    • Cheddar.
    • Parmesan.
    • Pecorino-Romano.
    • Goat Cheese.
    • Pepperoni is a frequent meat topping.
    • Hot Italian sausage.
    • Salami.
    • Bacon.
    • Chicken.

    Most Popular Vegetable Toppings

    On a pizza, you may put any vegetable topping you like. Any vegetable works well as a pizza topping, whether it be standard toppings such as mushrooms and peppers or uncommon toppings such as kale or roasted broccoli.

    The following are frequent vegetable toppings:

    • Mushrooms.
    • Onions.
    • Bell peppers.
    • Squash.
    • Artichoke hearts.
    • Corn.
    • Fresh or sun-dried tomatoes
    • black or green olives.
    • Fresh basil.
    • Arugula.
    • Pickled or fresh jalapenos

    The most unusual pizzas in America

    When you’re in the mood for anything other than pepperoni or buffalo chicken pizza, try one of the following interesting pizzas.

    Hawaiian Pizza

    Does pineapple go on pizza? Pizza aficionados have not reached a consensus on a single, conclusive answer to this question; the debate continues. The mix of sweet pineapple, salty ham or bacon, and savoury cheese creates the popular flavour combination known as Hawaiian pizza, which is relished by aficionados of a certain variety of pizza.

    Vegan Pizza

    Those who want to reduce or eliminate their consumption of meat and dairy but still enjoy the savoury attributes of pizza can try ordering a vegan pizza. Pizzas that adhere to the vegan diet have no animal-derived ingredients, including cheese. However, if you still need a pizza with the flavour and texture of melting, gooey cheese, you can have a pizza baked with vegan cheese.

    Do you currently have a strong craving for a piping hot pizza with all of your favourite toppings? At Pequod’s Pizza in Morton Grove or Chicago, you’ll discover precisely what you’re looking for, whether you enjoy America’s favourite pepperoni, mushroom, and extra cheese pizza or a caramelised deep-dish pizza. Pequod’s Pizza has been a local staple for decades.

    HomepageClick Here
    Ten Most Popular Pizza Toppings All Over The U.S.Click Here